WARNING: What follows is a really PMS-y tirade against a church service I went to this morning. Please understand that I am not saying these are bad people. I am saying that I AM A BAD PERSON and that I really, really, really, really, REALLY did not like the service I went to.
************************************
Oh, dear God, what a morning I had.
I’m determined to find a church for our family by the end of the year. Of course, something this important should be undertaken in the midst of the holidays and by oneself with little pre-planning. This is how all great decisions are reached, like….none that I can come up with, for instance.
Anyway, this morning I got up and got dressed for church, and went three blocks away to one in our neighborhood. I had taken Rabbit to a service there about five years ago and wasn’t thrilled with the pastor, but learned that he’d moved on and that they’d gotten a new one. Rabbit had also enjoyed vacation Bible school there one summer, and frequently asked me if we could go back.
So I took on the reconnaissance work of church shopping and arrived fifteen minutes before the start of the service so I could observe. Mostly, I found strikes against this particular church for us.
Strike One: Five of every six adults in attendance were at least 70 years old. This indicated to me an aging congregation that would end up the way our former church did, which was shrinking and diminishing until there were only about ten families in attendance, and almost no small children.
Strike Two: Only three or four kids were there, and all were under five. I’m sure they have more, but I don’t want Rabbit to be the only kid her age at church.
Strike Three: Only about one of every seven or eight persons in attendance was male. For my husband, this would be a deal breaker. A few old guys, one white haired hipster in a black turtleneck, a thirty-ish guy in a tweed jacket with a braid down his back, and that was about it.
Strike Four: Everything else.
Honestly, you guys. It was a terrible 90 minutes I spent smiling woodenly at earnest and well meaning people who didn’t get excited about anything, who sang out of tune, whose service was all the heck out of order, and whose pastor intoned in a slow, plaintive and meditative voice about things like “journeying to this place of expectation” and “advent is a season where we yearn to be in the birthplace of joy.”
Seriously, at times it was less like a church service and more like a really boring staging of The Vagina Monologues.
Here’s my problem with this morning. During the pastor’s sermon, she did not ONCE mention Jesus. I’m not even kidding. She talked about Advent and the approach to Christmas in smarmy terms like “a season of waiting” and “a time of peaceful organization of the trash that is in our lives” and then talked about how as a child, she would watch the Macy’s Thanksgiving Parade and always knew that the end of the parade, with Santa on a float, meant that Christmas was coming.
At least twice, she uttered the phrase “…at this point in time.” (Man, I am awful).
She mentioned a dog video she enjoyed on YouTube. She mentioned “that time of longing for joy, and the vulnerability we all must come to in order to embrace life’s joy. Vulnerability that manifests itself in a sigh before hearing the doctor’s results. Vulnerability in wondering if there’s enough money for the house payment. Vulnerability in going to war…”
Uh…I think you have vulnerability and anxiety confused.
The response to prayers of the congregation was this: ”God of grace and vulnerability, hear our prayers.”
Listen, sister. If I were looking for a vulnerable God, I would worship the underbelly of a turtle.
I know right now I sound like a horrible person and if you want to stop reading, please do because I kind of hate myself right now. But sweet merciful unmentioned Jesus, it was so awful. The music was dreadful. The three women up front behind the pastor all wore peasant skirts and dangly earrings and long flowy ponytails and swayed while they sang with their eyes closed.
They did the opening hymn sitting down. Then they had The Children’s Moment, where they explained what the Advent candles meant, while the kids ran back and forth on the altar. Then more music, and then the Lord’s Prayer, and then the Peace, and only then did they do the readings in the Bible. After that, the prayers of the people, and THEN the sermon.
This is a minor thing to many people, but I have grown accustomed to a certain order of things in a church service: Opening hymn, welcome, prayers, Psalm, response, Old Testament reading, response, Gospel, sermon, then prayers, then the offertory, then the Lord’s Prayer, then the Peace, then communion or similar, and then a final benediction and recessional song. Many mainline Protestant religions and the Catholic church follow this basic outline. It becomes a clock: during the Peace, you know that there’s communion and then the approach to the runway leading to time to leave and get groceries and make Sunday dinner.
I did not invent this: I just grew up with it.
I’ve been to other churches that don’t follow this outline at all. They have contemporary music and don’t dress up and have PowerPoint projections of song lyrics and the pastor wears jeans and on and on. Those don’t bother me as much as this morning did because this church seemed to be trying so terribly hard to be something it just was not. And I can’t think what that something might be, but it all felt as though it were falling way short of the mark.
It felt like….like an emasculation celebration. Is that a weird thing? It did – it felt like the island of Amazons, all blissed out on sacramental wine after a deep discussion group session and maybe some foot reflexology. It felt placid and innocuous – like eating a sandwich made of vanilla pudding between two slices of soft white bread.
I’m sure that they are all incredibly lovely people who care about each other and walk hand in hand fully expectant of the season of the birth of vulnerable joy, trembling in yearning for the Advent of grace and vulnerability. Or something.
But boy, it was SO not for me.