There’s a man living at my house who is a very strict traditionalist when it comes to church and religion. Don’t get me wrong, I’m not talking about his politics, I’m talking about his attitude toward the act of going to church and being in church.
1. You go to church, you wear nice clothes, the men should probably wear a tie, or at the least, a pressed shirt and nice pants – jeans are acceptable if worn with a nice shirt. Women, whatever you want to wear is fine but try not to look like you’re going on a date with Flavor Flav.
2. Church is dignified. Church should have its announcements in the bulletin, or at the beginning of the service. Gentle humor in the sermon is fine if it’s related to the liturgy. Lectors, please read exactly what is in the Bible and don’t add or skip words and practice pronunciation ahead of time.
3. There should be communion every time you go to church. You don’t leave right after communion, you go home after the recessional, and then you eat lunch and watch football.
4. The music should be done well, preferably with an organ and the choir. No rock bands. This is church, for God’s sake. If you want to go to a concert, buy a ticket and go to an amphitheater.
5. Church isn’t a party. It’s worship. Things are a certain way for a reason and you don’t screw around with them.
You see now why it took me a while to find a church he would agree to attend?
Our new church is pretty great – it’s very traditional, Lutheran, with solid music, a very established congregation, friendly people.
This past Sunday, we went to the service, which had been wildly promoted in the bulletin for three straight weeks beforehand. The announcements had promised the [Name Withheld] Puppets from [anonymous] church were going to be performing at both services. Naturally, I assumed they would have a few minutes of floor time during the five minutes the pastor reserves to talk to the little kids before he launches into his sermon each Sunday. I thought maybe a Lambchop sock puppet or something, to talk about how God loves his children. You know…..a moment or two and then back to the traditional churchiness of church.
First off, the parking lot was PACKED when we got there. People were milling around in the lobby, and smiling widely, and the chitchat factor was about 50% higher than normal. We got our bulletins and went inside to sit down and noticed that the back windows from the nave into the sanctuary were covered with black plastic sheeting and that all the window blinds were drawn over the stained glass.
And the altar? It was covered all the way across by ranks of shoulder-height curtains on rods, three levels of them following the altar steps. The curtains were moving in spots – clearly there were people milling around behind them, crouched down. The lectern, the actual altar, the chalice and Bible….all were out of view. And to the side, where our choir usually sits? A teenage boy I didn’t recognize was sitting at a drum set, and a blandly smiling man next to him strummed away on an electric guitar. I did not have a good feeling about where this was headed.
The pastor got up and, with a wooden smile that clearly conveyed that this production seven months into his new position at our church was a tradition he did not endorse and could not talk his staff out of, announced that the puppet troop from [anonymous] church was back for their third annual visit to our congregation. ”The floor is yours, Sandy,” he said, and handed off the mic, walking back to sit down in the front pew next to his wife, who struggled to contain her laughter.
Sandy, from [anonymous] church, intoned in a sleepy and blissful voice how glad they were to be with us, and would we all stand with her as they shared some worship music. Their electric guitar and drum set blammed into action, and Sandy started singing with her eyes closed and hands in the air, with muttered “Thank you, Jesus,” between verses.
I looked over at my husband, whose face had turned to stone, except for a pulsing muscle at his clenched jaw. My daughter yeeeeaaaawwwwned audibly, and I looked abruptly at my feet to allow my hair to fall like a curtain to shield my face so they couldn’t see me laughing.
But then? Oh dear God. Then came the puppets.
First, there was the trifecta of awful: A sassy teenage girl, carrying a ventriloquist dummy, which was a bird puppet. They did their bit after being introduced: Norman (the bird) was just having trouble learning how to pray. She tried to teach him the Lord’s prayer, which he butchered, line by line, ala “Who’s on First?” The kids laughed, and many adults chortled along. I was aghast. When the bird/puppet shouted “Halloween be my name!” I risked a look at my husband, who was glaring angrily toward the stage.
Next, they had the big puppet troop put on their show, to pre-recorded music over the sound system. And these weren’t like sock puppets: they were like MUPPETS. Fundamental Christian muppets, with that goose-down floaty hair, googly eyes, hinged mouths and felted skin. Singing. As puppet shows go, it wasn’t bad – the people operating them turned out to be mostly children, and they had their timing down very well.
Like I said, as a puppet show? Great. As a CHURCH SERVICE? You’ve got to be kidding. Because that was the whole service. Effing puppets. The worst was when they put out all the lights, plunging the church into complete darkness. Then the blacklights went on, and a puppet that looked like a two-foot-wide disembodied human mouth started singing a Christianized version of Aretha Franklin’s classic song “Respect.” With “background singers” that were these weird puppet creatures that looked like crinkle straws rising and falling, shrinking and expanding, back and forth, while singing “He sought me and he bought me and he sought me and he bought me…” instead of the original “Sock it to me sock it to me….”
You guys, it was absolutely dreadful. Kids were eating it up, but I was feeling squirmy and mortified. After the lights came back up, there was wild applause and then a man from [anonymous] church bounded up the aisle and announced the audience participation portion of the service. All I could picture was the Armageddon that would ensue if this man were unfortunate enough to point at my husband to come up to the front. Thankfully, PC was spared.
The nine volunteers were given cards that spelled out “S-A-L-V-A-T-I-O-N” and then there was a little schtik where the man sent them to sit down one by one until there was only the word “S-I-N” spelled out, and so on….. not unusual dogma for some churches, but absolutely not what is customary for our particular church. PC glanced over at me and said, angrily, ”I am never coming back here again.”
The ride home after church was mostly silent. ”That was awesome,” said Rabbit. ”Did you like it, Daddy?” PC paused and then said carefully “Well….I like that you liked it.”
After she went to her room to change, PC announced that he was going back to the Catholic church, never going to this new church again, etc., etc. Keep in mind, this was only about the fourth or fifth time he’d attended our new congregation. We argued for about 40 minutes, with me maintaining that this was an unfortunate fluke but not what the church was all about. He insisted he was done.
I left for my afternoon open houses. When I got home, PC said “I’ll go to the church, don’t worry. But only when there’s communion and NEVER for something like that puppet show. EVER AGAIN.”
On my morning walk today, four days later, I stopped in at the church and poked my head in the pastor’s office. He waved me in and I hemmed and hawed and then finally said “Can I weigh in with my opinion about Sunday’s service?” His eyes got wide and he grinned and said “Did you love it?”
I burst out laughing and said “No, it was horrible!” and he started to laugh and couldn’t stop. Turns out, it was, as we say, not a hill he wanted to die on. The act had been reserved long before he started at the church and part of building a rapport with your new congregation is to resist the urge to slash and burn and change things right off the bat.
I talked to him about PCs reaction, and we visited about why it had upset him so much. Between earnestly discussing what is sacred in church and what is not, we kept laughing about the fact that we’d had to sit through an hour of puppets against our will (in his case, TWO SERVICES IN A ROW).
I really respect that the pastor of our church didn’t just come out and say “No way, we’re not doing this,” even though he could have, in order to be respectful of decisions that had been made before he started. I also respected how he took the time to listen to me when I said “No way, I can’t believe we did this,” and to talk with me about getting together with PC to explain to him that this puppet show wasn’t what our church was really about.
The whole thing was surreal and funny and dreadfully cheesy and godawful. I know there are churches that have drama teams and rock music and skits and other things they incorporate into their Sunday message. I don’t disrespect that. Really, I don’t. But to take that method of worship and inject it into a setting that is otherwise very traditional and structured, and make that an hour of showmanship instead of a regular church service….it was jarring. For my husband, it was absolute torture.
I’m not trying to start a debate about theology. But really…..PUPPETS?

